Best Storage Format for Mac Users: A Comprehensive Guide

Photo by amt8u on Unsplash

If you are a Mac user who recently bought a hard disk, you might be wondering which storage format you should use. Choosing the right storage format is crucial as it affects your disk’s compatibility, performance, and data security. In this article, we’ll discuss the various storage format options available to Mac users, their advantages and disadvantages, and provide reference links for all the facts discussed.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Different Storage Formats Available for Mac Users
3. Advantages and Disadvantages of Each Format
4. How to Format Your Hard Disk on a Mac
5. FAQs
6. Conclusion
7. What Did I Choose?
8. Reference Links

1. Introduction

As a Mac user, you have several options for formatting your hard disk. The storage format you choose determines how your data is organized on the disk and how it can be accessed by your Mac and other devices. Each format has its own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to choose one that best fits your needs. In this article, we’ll cover the most popular storage formats for Mac users, including Mac OS Extended (HFS+), Apple File System (APFS), ExFAT, FAT32, and NTFS.

2. Different Storage Formats Available for Mac Users

1. Mac OS Extended (HFS+)

Mac OS Extended, also known as HFS+, is the default file system for Macs running macOS 10.3 Panther and later versions. HFS+ supports large file sizes, offers built-in support for file compression, and provides fast read and write speeds. However, it is not compatible with Windows and other operating systems without third-party software.

2. Apple File System (APFS)

Apple File System (APFS) is the default file system for Macs running macOS 10.13 High Sierra and later versions. APFS offers improved performance and faster file copying than HFS+, supports snapshots for data backup and recovery, and offers better support for solid-state drives (SSDs). It is also compatible with iOS, watchOS, and tvOS. However, it is not compatible with older versions of macOS and has limited compatibility with Windows.

3. ExFAT

ExFAT (Extended File Allocation Table) is a file system developed by Microsoft that is supported by both Windows and macOS. ExFAT supports large file sizes and is ideal for transferring files between Macs and PCs. However, it does not support file permissions and has limited support for data backup and recovery.

4. FAT32

FAT32 is an older file system that is supported by both Windows and macOS. It has good compatibility with older hardware and operating systems and supports file sizes up to 4GB. However, it has limited support for file permissions and offers no built-in data backup and recovery features.

5. NTFS

NTFS (New Technology File System) is a file system developed by Microsoft that is primarily used on Windows PCs. It offers improved performance and supports file sizes larger than 4GB. However, it has limited support on Macs and requires third-party software to write to NTFS-formatted drives.

3. Advantages and Disadvantages of Each Format

1. Mac OS Extended (HFS+)

Advantages:

• Compatibility: HFS+ is compatible with all Mac operating systems, which makes it a popular choice for many Mac users.
• Metadata: HFS+ stores metadata, such as file creation date and file modification date, which makes it easier to organize files and search for them.
• Journaling: HFS+ has a journaling feature that helps prevent data loss in case of unexpected shutdowns or system crashes.
• Large file support: HFS+ supports large file sizes, which makes it suitable for storing multimedia files.

Disadvantages:

• Limited compatibility with other operating systems: HFS+ is not compatible with Windows or Linux operating systems, which can make it difficult to share files with users on those platforms.
• Fragmentation: HFS+ can become fragmented over time, which can lead to slower read and write speeds.
• File corruption: In some cases, HFS+ can become corrupted, which can result in data loss or other issues.
• Older technology: HFS+ is an older technology that has been replaced by the newer APFS format, which offers several improvements over HFS+.

2. Apple File System (APFS)

Advantages:

• Improved performance and faster file copying than HFS+.
• Supports snapshots for data backup and recovery.
• Offers better support for solid-state drives (SSDs).
• Compatible with iOS, watchOS, and tvOS.

Disadvantages:

• Limited compatibility with older versions of macOS.
• Limited compatibility with Windows.

3. ExFAT

Advantages:

• Supports large file sizes and is ideal for transferring files between Macs and PCs.
• Compatible with both Windows and macOS.

Disadvantages:

• Does not support file permissions.
• Limited support for data backup and recovery.

4. FAT32

Advantages:

• Good compatibility with older hardware and operating systems.
• Supports file sizes up to 4GB.
• Compatible with both Windows and macOS.

Disadvantages:

• Limited support for file permissions.
• Offers no built-in data backup and recovery features.

5. NTFS

Advantages:

• Offers improved performance and support file sizes larger than 4GB.
• Compatible with Windows.

Disadvantages:

• Limited support on Macs.
• Requires third-party software to write to NTFS-formatted drives.

4. How to Format Your Hard Disk on a Mac

To format your hard disk on a Mac, follow these steps:

1. Connect your hard disk to your Mac.
2. Open the Disk Utility app.
3. Select your hard disk from the list of drives on the left.
4. Click on the “Erase” button.
5. Choose the storage format you want to use.
6. Enter the name of your hard disk.
7. Click on the “Erase” button to start the formatting process.

5. FAQs

What happens if I choose the wrong storage format for my hard disk?

If you choose the wrong storage format, you may experience compatibility issues and data loss. It’s important to choose the right format based on your needs and the devices you’ll be using with your hard disk.

Also, it’s a pain to reformat the hard disk, we need to take a backup of the complete drive, for which we might need to buy another hard disk. So better format it in the right format and stick to it, until it becomes incompatible.

Can I change the storage format of my hard disk after I’ve already formatted it?

Yes, you can change the storage format of your hard disk by reformatting it. However, reformatting will erase all the data on your hard disk, so make sure to back up your data before reformatting.

Note: I’ve formatted it to APFS, and I’m using Mac OS Ventura, Mac doesn’t allow me to reformat the hard disk to other formats

After doing my research I figured out
Once you have formatted your hard disk to APFS, it is not possible to format it back to other file systems using the Disk Utility app on your Mac. This is because APFS is the default file system for macOS High Sierra and later versions.

However, if you need to use a different file system such as exFAT or FAT32, you can use third-party software to format your drive. There are several third-party formatting tools available for macOS that allow you to format your drive in different file systems. Some popular options include:

• Paragon Partition Manager: This is a powerful disk management tool that allows you to create, format, and resize partitions on your Mac. It supports a wide range of file systems, including exFAT and FAT32.
  Catch: Only Intel-based Macs are supported
• Disk Drill: This is a data recovery software that also includes disk management tools. It allows you to format your drive in different file systems, including exFAT and FAT32. It has a nice
  Catch: You need the pro/paid version to format

• iPartition: This is another popular disk management tool for Mac that allows you to create, delete, and resize partitions on your hard drive. It supports a wide range of file systems, including exFAT and FAT32.

Before using any third-party software, make sure to back up all of your important data and read the documentation carefully to ensure that you understand how to use the software correctly. Additionally, keep in mind that third-party software may have different performance and reliability characteristics than the built-in Disk Utility app.

Is there a storage format that works with both Mac and Windows without third-party software?

ExFAT is the only storage format that is natively supported by both Mac and Windows without third-party software.

Note: This is the format I maintain on my secondary hard disk, whenever I need to watch something on TV or share some data with anyone. Since it’s cross-platform compatible, I need not worry about people coming back and saying “It’s not working”

Can I use third-party software to write to NTFS-formatted drives on my Mac?

Yes, you can use third-party software to write to NTFS-formatted drives on your Mac. By default, macOS only allows you to read from NTFS drives, not write to them. However, there are several third-party applications available that can enable write access to NTFS drives.

Here are some popular third-party applications you can use to write to NTFS drives on your Mac:

1. Paragon NTFS for Mac: This is a paid application that provides full read-and-write access to NTFS-formatted drives on your Mac. It is a reliable and fast option that is frequently updated to support the latest macOS versions.
2. Tuxera NTFS for Mac: This is another paid application that allows you to write to NTFS drives on your Mac. It provides fast and stable performance and supports all macOS versions.
3. NTFS for Mac by iBoysoft: This is a relatively new and affordable option that provides read-and-write access to NTFS-formatted drives on your Mac. It is easy to use and has a simple interface.
4. FUSE for macOS: This is a free and open-source application that allows you to write to NTFS drives on your Mac. It requires some technical knowledge to install and use, but it is a reliable and well-supported option.

Please note that using third-party software to write to NTFS drives may have some risks associated with it, such as data corruption or loss. Make sure to back up your important data before attempting to write to NTFS drives using third-party software.

Is it better to use a solid-state drive (SSD) or a hard disk drive (HDD) for my Mac?

SSDs offer faster performance and are more durable than HDDs, but they are also more expensive. It ultimately depends on your budget and performance needs.

6. Conclusion

Choosing the right storage format for your hard disk is crucial to ensure compatibility, performance, and data security. Mac users have several options to choose from, including Mac OS Extended (HFS+), Apple File System (APFS), ExFAT, FAT32, and NTFS. Each format has its own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to choose one that best fits your needs. Remember to back up your data before formatting your hard disk, and consider using third-party software if needed.

7. What Did I Choose?

My main requirement is to store photos and videos.

When it comes to storing a photo and video library, it’s important to choose the right format to ensure that your precious memories are safe and easily accessible.

After considering my options, I’ve decided to store my collection as a Mac Photos Library, as it provides useful features such as a timeline, place-wise view, a map view, and more. However, the choice of the hard disk format can also have a significant impact on the performance and compatibility of the Photos Library.

Initially, I stored my photos in the exFAT format, which offered compatibility with both Mac and Windows systems. However, I discovered that the Photos app on my Mac no longer supports exFAT, which means that I was unable to take advantage of the latest features and updates.

That’s why I’ve decided to store my Photos Library on an APFS-formatted hard disk. APFS is a modern file system that has been optimized for macOS and provides improved performance, reliability, and security compared to older file systems like exFAT.

In particular, APFS is designed to handle large files and directories efficiently, which makes it an ideal choice for storing a Photos Library with many images and videos. Additionally, APFS also includes features like built-in encryption, snapshotting, and fast directory sizing, which help ensure the safety and security of your data.

In summary, I’ve chosen to store my Photos Library on an APFS-formatted hard disk because of its superior performance and compatibility with the latest version of macOS. I am confident that my photo and video collection will be easily accessible, safe, and secure for years to come.

8. Reference Links

1. Apple Support — About file system formats: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208496
2. Macworld — Which Mac file system is best for an external drive? https://www.macworld.com/article/3268989/which-mac-file-system-is-best-for-an-external-drive.html
3. How-To Geek — APFS vs. Mac OS Extended: Which One Should You Use on a Mac? https://www.howtogeek.com/367599/apfs-vs-mac-os-extended-which-one-should-you-use-on-a-mac/
4. Mac Observer — Which File System Should Your Mac Use? https://www.macobserver.com/tips/quick-tip/mac-file-system/
5. Lifewire — Which Mac File System Is Best for an External Drive? https://www.lifewire.com/which-mac-file-system-is-best-for-an-external-drive-4164484